Replies to Billy Mitchell’s Blog

Bill,

Yes, maybe I should restate what I actually think and believe. I believe economists are missing data that would clarify the two major problems afflicting modern technologically advanced economies, namely chronic scarcity of individual incomes and inflation that lead to those economy’s instability. They are missing it because they are simply not looking in the correct place where that data can be garnered and calculus applied to it in order to see its dynamic systemic destabilizing effects. Deciphering this would make clear the policies necessary to stabilize the system. All of the current cutting edge research and theories align with and are converging on the philosophy and policies of the new theory and paradigm that I hope economic theory is awakening to. For instance General Disequilibrium/Flux/Process (Steve Keen) instead of General Equilibrium, monetary addition/abundance (MMT) instead of monetary scarcity/austerity/subtraction, both structural and central (Public Banking) instead of the hiding in plain sight 800 pound monopolistic gorilla of Private Finance and finally integrating individual and systemic monetary grace/Gifting into profit making systems instead of always being “behind the curve” of the increasingly disruptive effects on aggregate individual incomes due to the logics of efficiency that drive and dictate profit making systems, technological innovation and AI.

****************************************************

Alan,
“The only relevance between Quantum theory and economics is that economists have hijacked some of the maths in an attempt to validate their scientism – it’s not fooling me though.”

Yes, I completely agree with this. Scientism is really just the flip side of religiosity. I recommend a paraphrase of the well known zen koan: What is the sound of scientism and religiosity clapping?

Posted to Billy Mitchell’s Blog 11/16/2015

All of the delusive thinking and consciously bought regressive monopolistic forces come out at times like the 30’s and like now. They were wrong then, they are wrong now. OMF is enlightened….as far as it goes. It’s only real problem is it only goes from private finance….to public finance. It needs to be extended all the way to the individual. That doesn’t mean the government can’t additionally fund infrastructure etc. Of course it can, and of course it should…with reasonably prudent overseeing so that we don’t end up building thousands of “bridges to no where” and also don’t end up with 5 powers with armies and navies the size of the US.

I know you desire not to have a discussion of Social Credit here Bill, but the relevance of facts like C. H. Douglas’s speaking tour of Japan in 1929 which was enthusiastically received if fascistically twisted by the imperialistic/militaristic forces there….cannot be ignored.

You are correct to point out that hyper-inflation is not a credible critique as it requires a compliant central bank to lend to speculators so that they can short the currency and destroy it as was the case in Weimar. And you are also correct in saying that inflation was not a significant factor in Japan as well, but that was mostly because the war was on and war is always “good business.” Inflation however would have and will occur because….who and what is to stop businesses from raising their prices as they see demand rising? The situation cries out for a macro-economic policy like a rebated back to participating merchants retail discount to the consumer. If you don’t do that the regressive and monopolistic financial powers and their austerian lackeys will (correctly) carp on and on about 3-5% inflation until OMF is politically reversed. Put sufficient dividend and macro discount mechanisms in there and drive a stake through the heart of the 5000 year old problematic business model of private finance…once and for all.

Unconsciousness of the Costing/Pricing System

It never ceases to amaze me that economists can say things like “the fundamental direction of capitalist/profit making systems is up.” ….and then they make no attempt to deal with this fact policy wise. It ought to be a given that a macro-economic policy is called for in view of the statement, no? It’s either the economist is unconscious, or has no clue how to craft such a policy. I strongly suggest it is the latter, because that very statement was made by someone who I consider one of the leading economists on the planet. Actually it is a combination of both. Most economists are unconscious of the costing/pricing system and how time and additional costs are an inherent aspect of commercial operations themselves. In fact the same economist who made the above statement also said one of the reasons why economists are so ignorant of how the monetary economy operates was that they could get their economics degree without so much as taking a single course in accounting.  This was another excellent observation on the inadequacies of the curriculum of economics, and yet I told this same economist that he should investigate the empirical data in what is referred to as cost accounting which is the “on the ground” 3 and 4 dimensional aspect of accounting….and there was no response to my suggestion. This strongly denotes a lack of reality regarding accounting and the costing/pricing system that every enterprise must adhere to. Cost accounting is both a blessing and a curse because it is an excellent tool for determining whether or not the business is profitable or not, but also enforces a flawed convention on businesses, namely that all costs must go into price. This despite the fact that commercial enterprises always generate more costs than they distribute in individual incomes…with which to liquidate those costs.Hence the economy is systemically cost inflationary. In other words its fundamental costing and pricing system is “upward” despite there not being an equal amount of individual incomes. This is the most fundamental problem of the economic and monetary system and can only be remedied with a costless monetary gift to the individual and a means of reversing the systemic cost inflation at the correct point in the productive process, that is by a discount to prices at retail sale to the individual.
It pays to be conscious of cost accounting and the costing/pricing system of commerce

The Most Fruitful Activity One Can Engage In

Study and contemplate the aspects of the natural experience of Grace.  The definition and most basic component parts of the natural experience of Grace are: Space, Time and Self Awareness.

Thus Grace is or is an essential and actual component part of….everything and everyone….your self included.

Contemplating Grace is the naturalization of spirituality and the re-sacralization of nature….at the same time….if one avoids the pitfalls of religiosity. This is because the experience of Grace is the ultimate integration above.

Speech: The Paralyzing Subtlety of Our Economic and Monetary Slavery

We are economically and monetarily enslaved. There must not be any doubt about this. Unfortunately the systems involved are so complex and so suavely able to disguise the fact that a great deal of sophistry and delusion have built up around them and been used to justify the slavery as inevitable and/or claim that it is indeed…freedom. All dualistic argumentation is ultimately vanity. However, integration of dualities is Wisdom and the end result of continuous economic and monetary integration is the concept and/or natural experience of Grace as in micro-economic flow, macro-economic free flowingness and individual economic and monetary freedom. That is a trinity-unity of freedom and flow. Thirdness and oneness are essential understandings regarding, and the very signature of, freedom and flow, and mere un-integrated dualism is the signature of continual contention. Therefore endlessly debating whether or not the system is enslaving is failure, and deciding to actively create freedom via a philosophy of Grace as per above, and its aligned policies…is the answer. Action to effect immanent and actual freedom for all agents and individuals and thus for the system is therefore the necessary…now.

Post to Andrew Lainton’s Blog

Capitalism is the social system that places capital above the individual, and Socialism is the social system that places government above the individual. Distributism is the system that considers the individual and his/her freedom first and places them above but within a system of profit.

Posted to Billy Mitchell’s Blog 11/16/2015

Scarcity as monetary and economic policy is so patently absurd, such an ossified orthodoxy and so obviously the self interested policy of the Banking and Financial systems that we should call for mass rallies of uproarious and derisive laughter as a tactic of un-hypnotizing neo-liberal economists and awakening and emboldening the mass of the populace to the necessity of change. Wisdom is integration and the integrative process, and Flow is simply continuous integration. Let us integrate more abundant monetary and economic policies into our theorizing. I do not see how we could go wrong by doing so.

Responce to Simonsky

Simonsky:  Bill,it’s worth pointing out that Dennet’s words refer to religious belief and not economic one’s (although features may be shared). I regard Dennet as an inapposite reference for the following reasons:

1. Evolutionary biology has been, implicitly and explicitly, used as a pseudo-scientific justification for neo-liberalism.

2. Dawkins and Dennet NEVER make reference to oligarchy/kleptocracy in our economic system, indeed, their theories are often used as a basis for it by others.

3. Socio-biology emerged in the mid 70’s JUST at the same time as neo-liberalism started gaining ground (banking deregulation/ associating public spending with inflation etc) this is no chance event in my view.

If one reads the work of biologists on the left (Rose, Lewontin) the political and economic/ideological roots of the Dawkins/Dennet ‘axis’ are explored.

Me:  Simonsky,
I don’t disagree with your point, but orthodoxy and religiosity hide everywhere including so called science. Science is a wonderful and necessary tool, but we are best guided by the world’s Wisdom traditions which, stripped of their supernaturalism, are truly integrative natural philosophies, and if integrated with cutting edge quantum physics could also be the basis for a truly modern spirituality as well. You can’t trust either science or religion to be adequate human philosophies and generally a life that ends up being gracious and holistic is not possible without aspects of both. So what does one do? Integrate! Integrate! Integrate! Continuous integration!

Brief Critique of Economic and Monetary Theories, Their Comparison to Wisdomics/Gracenomics and the Relevance of The Cosmic Code

All present theories have particles of truth and untruth in them as well as false or outmoded orthodoxies, gaps in their observations/theories and biases whether conscious or unconscious. The more they integrate the more comprehensive, accurate and whole they are. Wisdomics/Gracenomics is the most integrated of all of them.

Austrian-Libertartianism is predicated on letting the economy alone as if it were God which is merely an orthodoxy.

All Neo-liberal economic and monetary theory is predicated on General Equilibrium which is also merely and orthodoxy.

All Disequilibrium economic theory or Modern Monetary Theory is predicated on the Banks still having final control of credit creation, and also still cling to orthodoxies regarding employment as a problem.

Public Banking and Positive Money do not account for the scarcity of individual incomes as a flow being less than the flow of costs/prices. .

None of the above includes a discount mechanism so as to handle inflation and actually positively create deflation within a profit making system.

Social Credit still has orthodoxies that most of its adherents cling to whether they be inconsequential pre-scientific religious biases or dangerous ones like not recognizing that the powers of money creation must be taken away from Private Banking or orthodoxies about there needing to be a specific set level of dividend payment and discount percentage when there are multiple and very flexible levels of each. The only truly important factor is that the combination of the two policy mechanisms of Social Credit actually and immanently create a satisfactory level of economic freedom and abundance to prevent anyone from considering themselves a second class citizen. This is a policy of Wisdomic/Gracenomics.

Wisdomics/Gracenomics has all of the necessary aspects of resolving the problem and none of the mereness, gaps in theory, biases or conscious or unconscious adherence to orthodoxies….and it also is a natural philosophy of spirituality and consciousness so it has transcended transcendentalism and yet simultaneously includes  it….because Wisdom embraces integrated Bothness (Duality) and Grace embraces and is integrated Bothness (Duality) and Andness-Oneness (addition and wholeness i.e. Trinity-Unity).

The Cosmic Code applies to all human systems, particularly the economic, financial and monetary systems.

The Cosmic Code:  2 Within 3 Within 1

{ [ (A X B) X C ] } = 1

(A X B) = 2 (Duality)

[ (A X B) X C ] = 3 (Trinity)

{ [ (A X B) X C ] } = 1 (Unity-Oneness)

Posted to Ellen Brown’s Forum 11/15/2015

Me:  I’m liking and re-affirming my appreciation for the mentioning of “a national dividend”. Repetition, like number of times over the lesson in education, is one of the best and most basic routes to an idea “sticking” in the minds of learners.

I also like Matt Stannard’s puncturing of Neo-liberal economics’ thinking that postal/public banking is anti-competitive. Finance needs to be a public utility. What public utilities need is the guidance of the ethic and paradigm of natural Grace….as does any human activity.

Ellen Brown:  Yep repetition is what we do. Same message and moral, every show and article! First they laugh, then they fight you, then they say “that’s what I said all along.”

Me:  Yep, yep, yep! And the corollary, when you know something is basically and yet also inclusively right….ignoring the critics, the advocates of less inclusive orthodoxies and the bought and sold….is actually the correct thing to do.